Wednesday, March 5, 2014

America at High Noon



One of the alluring aspects of the story of St. George and the dragon is the individual, solitary effort of St. George. The dragon had been a real problem and the elders  had been unable to solve it--giving up their young women to the dragon.  But St. George, without having to organize any group, without having to think about regulations, simply rode out on his horse and dispatched the dragon. One man: problem solved.
It's a story we have told in different forms through the ages:  Gary Cooper, at High Noon, has to face the gang of killers alone. Ultimately, he has to rely on himself, as every man in this life does. In the end, we are all alone. We come into t he world alone and we depart alone. The solitary soul. Odysseus may travel with companions, but in the end, he is washed up on his home shore alone.

In the real world, however, at least in the 21st century,  what one man can accomplish alone, is limited. Dragons who can be killed by a single knight on horseback are now few and far between. Most really important problems today cannot be solved by a single brave man, of great resolve and strength.  They require lots of people and lots of organization.
Ulysses S. Grant solved the greatest problem of his age, but not alone. He was single minded, but he did not act alone. 
He would show up at the tent of a subordinate general, his eyes fastened on the tops of his own shoes, kicking dirt, shoulders hunched, listening to the subordinate's explanations of his problems, why his army could not move from its current position, but the soldiers watching the conversation always knew: When Grant showed up, there would be fighting soon. 
The fox is very clever and knows many things; the hedgehog is not so clever, and he knows only one thing, but he knows it well.  Grant knew one thing: He had to engage the enemy, to keep in constant contact, to keep the pressure on Lee and Lee's army. He knew that territory, arms, supply lines, cities--none of that would win the war. He knew his one objective was to meet the enemy army and destroy it. 
After the war, one of the great Southern generals was asked how the Army of Northern Virginia had been brought to defeat. What logistical problems, what economic problems, what strategic problems had led to defeat?  "I think the Union army likely had something to do with it," he said, in the end. 

Grant was the force which drove that army.
But that took other people, organization, getting people to  swing into action.
Reading Raffi Khatchadourian's  long, excellent article in the New Yorker  (March 3), the long, complicated, push to develop a hydrogen nuclear plant which could produce an inexhaustible supply of energy for everyone on earth, out of abundant hydrogen, one has to appreciate how much working together, as frustrating and inefficient as it may be, is the only way to achieve really enormous goals. 

Albert Einstein did not make the atomic bomb in his garage. A large group of men did that. 

For all their insistence that government is the problem, the Tea Party, Joe Sixpack, the heart and soul of the Republican Party have cleaved to one, central idea: We do not need each other; we do not need group effort. It's really every man for himself in this life and that's the way it ought to be.

It's a seductive idea, especially in income tax season. But it is a bankrupt idea.
The fact is, solitary confinement is no joy.
We do more and do better in groups. 
We just don't like to admit it. 

2 comments:

  1. Mad Dog,
    Those pesky Republicans do embrace that heroic, lone maverick myth lock stock and barrel (sorry I couldn't resist)..How did you enjoy the opening day of CPAC? Wasn't Mitch McConnell a vision brandishing his rifle over his head, like Davy Crockett, but did you notice he looked a little self conscious when doing it. Like he knew what he was doing was silly and pandering but he's up for re-election and a guy's gotta do what a guy's gotta do..Ted Cruz was all fired up, when isn't he, "every single word of Obamacare must be repealed" blah,blah, blah-nothing new there, but the "Nut of The Day " award has to go to the NRA's own Wayne LaPierre warning against "home invaders, drug cartels, carjackers,knockout gamers and rapers, and haters and campus killers and airport killers, and shopping mall killers" Yikes, seems Mr. Lapierre has a little anxiety, what type of arsenal does he sleep with and what exactly is a knockout gamer?. Oh and of course he had to throw in that you can't trust government because"government itself has proved unworthy of our trust. We trust ourselves'. Oh Shane, I mean Wayne...What do you thing they'll do for the grand finale of this cavalcade of kooks-maybe a stage filled with a battalion of majorettes twirling rifles instead of batons...

    I haven't read the article on the hydrogen nuclear plant, but it sounds interesting and will go back and read it...
    Maud

    ReplyDelete
  2. Maud,

    What HAVE I been missing? Yikes!
    CPAC throws the Paranoia Ball. Or is that the Paranormal Ball? Or the Parallax View Ball?
    Did McConnell wear a coonskin cap? I still have mine from age 8. I was depressed for weeks when Walt Disney killed off Davy and Jim Bowie at the Alamo. That engendered a life long distrust of Mexicans, which proved to be well founded, when at age 39, a Mexican diplomat's son crashed his car head on in mine and put my wife in the hospital for two months. It was our own private Alamo.
    Not to mention Texas. Cannot trust Texas. Now you cannot get an abortion in Texas, at least not in most of Texas.
    They execute more people in Texas than in all of Russia, but they do believe in life.
    I will go on line to see if I can see Mr. LaPierre's rant.
    Guns don't kill people...And cigarettes are good for your health--they relieve stress.
    "It is difficult to bring a man to understanding when his income depends on his not understanding," to paraphrase Upton Sinclair.

    Mad Dog

    ReplyDelete