The New Yorker put Alexis Navalny's image on its cover this week and I thought: Donald Trump is about to take over the government in three weeks--there's an election going on: Why would you be thinking about a Russian dissident, even if he was murdered by Vladimir Putin?
This man who died 8 months ago, in Russia. He's not of the current moment.
Right now, we've got our own problems, right here in the U.S. of A.
I resisted reading it.
But after I got done with Adam Gopnik's typically trenchant analysis of the Trump problem--"No matter how deranged his behavior is, though, it does not seem to alter his good fortune."--I slid by the article on whether birds can talk to each other, and another on Kamala Harris's chances, and there was "Prison Diaries," and I said, "Okay, I'll read just the first entry, and then move on to the Cartoon Caption Contest."
But, after the first entry, I was hooked.
Nalvany's voice, even in English, is clear and beguiling--it's like reading Dostoevsky as read by Andrei Codrescu, droll, chatty, absurdist, intoxicating.
"The first is frequently to be found in self-help books: Imagine the worst thing that can happen, and accept it. This works, even if it's a masochistic exercise. I can imagine that it's not suitable for people suffering from clinical depression. They might do it so successfully that they end up hanging themselves."
Nalvany is in prison, and not one of those white collar prisons for rich aristocrats who fudged their book keeping and wound up scamming banks for a few tens of millions of dollars, a Russian prison where you sit on a wood bench under a portrait of Putin for hours so you can engage in "disciplinary activity."
But he is not one to feel sorry for himself. He says he made his choices and accepts the consequences, unlike the Ukrainian parents who were "Just living their lives. They had jobs. They were family breadwinners. Then, one fine evening, a vengeful runt on television, the President of a neighboring country, announces that you are all 'Nazis' and have to die because Ukraine was invented by Lenin." So, "Right now, dead civilians are lying in the streets in Mariupol, their bodies gnawed at by dogs."
As he sits in prison, more and more charges are brought against him, as the opaque Russian state moves against him, which is to say, Putin moves against him.
"Some people collect stamps. Some collect coins. And I have a growing collection of amazing court trials."
Finally, Navalny realizes how much Putin and his cadre really fear him: they move him to a gulag in the far north, the Artic Circle. It's not enough to have him deep inside a stone prison 300 miles from Moscow; he has to be really far away for Putin to feel safe, where the temperatures outside are -26 degrees F.
"Today I went for a walk, got frozen and thought of Leonardo DiCaprio and his character's dead horse trick in 'The Revenant.' I don't think it would work here. A dead horse would freeze in about fifteen minutes."
I have never seen that movie, but I am sure I know exactly what that trick was.
"Here you need an elephant. A hot or even a roasted elephant. If you cut open the belly of a freshly roasted elephant and crawl inside, you can keep warm for a while. But where am I going to get a hot roasted elephant in Yamal?"
Navalny died almost exactly 3 years after he returned to Russia and was arrested as soon as he landed.
His fate was sealed the moment he stepped off that plane.
Vladimir Putin was never going to allow him to live, much less to speak to the Russian people.
One wonders why Putin bothered to prolong the agony, but as you read Navalny, you understand. Drawing out the process plays into the narrative.
Putin is not a ruthless king, nor a Stalin who simply shoots people in the head. In Putin's Russia, they pretend there are laws and processes and they even have lawyers. But all that is just for show.
I know what you are going to say--how different are we here in the USA? After all, Jeffrey Epstein died in prison and nobody asked any questions. Donald Trump was President.
Someone asked Donald Trump about what he was willing to do as President: Was he willing to order to have people killed? "Oh?" Trump said, "You don't think American Presidents kill people?"
Of course, President Obama had ordered the killing of Osama Bin Laden and celebratory crowds gathered outside the White House to congratulate him.
Donald Trump does not ask about the law. He asks about the judge.
Putin, of course, is the law. But Trump can, in fact, exert his will through others now. He has a Supreme Court which no longer even pretends to care about the law, about precedent, which has made separation of church and state unconstitutional, which declared billions spent to support candidates as simply free speech, which embraces the idea we have the best government money can buy, which, in his second term, has said it will reverse gay marriage and is open to considering allowing state laws to forbid inter racial marriage. (The last oddity is especially odd since it was floated by a Black justice who is married to a White woman who seemed to embrace this idea; odd, of course, unless he is looking for a way out of his marriage short of divorce. Having your marriage set aside without the cost of divorce lawyers may have some appeal. Or maybe this was simply a sly appeal to Black men who Trump has been courting.)
When Hitler invaded Poland, he claimed he was defending Germans living within its borders, and the same for Czechoslovakia. Autocrats are always rescuing some down trodden group, sometimes on horseback, riding shirtless. Putin is rescuing Ukraine from Nazis, although nobody has yet claimed he has crossed the border on horseback, shirtless. Trump is the father of in vitro fertilization and the protector of women. And like most strong man wannabes, he is, well, strong, or at least he talks as if he were strong, and, well, a man.
But there will always be Trumps, Putin's, Hitler's, Orban's, Mussolini's, and, for that matter, Jim Jones's around.
|
Tough Guy |
|
Not Such a Tough Guy: Sic Semper Tyranis |
The only real question is whether there are enough true believers to drink their Kool Aide.